Post by Host Ben on Feb 28, 2011 0:32:25 GMT -4
Both tribes did very well on their artwork, but it isn't up to me, or Rob. It's up to our three mystery judges.
Tortuga's Submission:
Comments from Host One:
Creativity...There's somethign that is lacking....like somehow I'm not really impressed....I'd say 3/10.
Connection...There isn't really a lot of rambling in the pictures...just Eliza looking shocked or facial expressions. I'd say 6/10
Artistic Merit...There is much to be desired with the entire picture. There would be a LOT I could do myself to actually improve this picture, tbh. I'd say 3/10 as well.
Comments from Judge Two:
Comments from Judge Three:
That leaves Tortuga with a total score of 46.
Tortuga's Submission:
Comments from Judge One:
Comments from Judge Two:
Comments from Judge Three:
That gives Beagle a score of 83.
Beagle Tribe wins immunity!
Tribal Council and Urn Room will be open soon. Patricia, we need a representative from Beagle for Tribal Council. If you don't choose someone in the next two hours, I'll pick somebody randomly.
Tortuga's Submission:
Comments from Host One:
Creativity...There's somethign that is lacking....like somehow I'm not really impressed....I'd say 3/10.
Connection...There isn't really a lot of rambling in the pictures...just Eliza looking shocked or facial expressions. I'd say 6/10
Artistic Merit...There is much to be desired with the entire picture. There would be a LOT I could do myself to actually improve this picture, tbh. I'd say 3/10 as well.
Comments from Judge Two:
Okay well...for creativity...
+1 for the Eliza rambling. It was a cute idea.
+1 for attempting to make it look like she was actually rambling.
+1 for an attempt at tribal pride.
CREATIVITY: 3
For connecting the image to the phrase...it was a simple concept...so simple to execute I suppose...
+4 for using Eliza images.
-1 for none of the images being of her actually talking. LOL
+4 for them making up for it with words.
CONNECTED: 7
ARTISTIC MERIT: 0
I'm sorry, but it's a disaster. -.- I'd trash it instantly.
+1 for the Eliza rambling. It was a cute idea.
+1 for attempting to make it look like she was actually rambling.
+1 for an attempt at tribal pride.
CREATIVITY: 3
For connecting the image to the phrase...it was a simple concept...so simple to execute I suppose...
+4 for using Eliza images.
-1 for none of the images being of her actually talking. LOL
+4 for them making up for it with words.
CONNECTED: 7
ARTISTIC MERIT: 0
I'm sorry, but it's a disaster. -.- I'd trash it instantly.
Comments from Judge Three:
Red and Lime look terrible together.
Creativity: 9. Title Connection: 10. Artistic Merit: 5
Creativity: 9. Title Connection: 10. Artistic Merit: 5
That leaves Tortuga with a total score of 46.
Tortuga's Submission:
Comments from Judge One:
Creativity...I must say, WOW! This is so good! I'm not sure I could come up with a vacuum or zooms for Z & V. Very nicely done! Very well done! I'd say 10/10
Connection... Although I don't see how John would be zooming on a vacuum with no power, the picture actually looks hilarious and I could see him trying to ride it like a stick horse. Easily 10/10
Artistic Merit...Kudos for getting everything to mesh well with the whole picture! Nothing on this picture makes me want to claw my eyes out from the strain of reading! The only thing I would have done (if possible) would have been to get the vacuum posed differently. But other than that this is great! 9/10.
Connection... Although I don't see how John would be zooming on a vacuum with no power, the picture actually looks hilarious and I could see him trying to ride it like a stick horse. Easily 10/10
Artistic Merit...Kudos for getting everything to mesh well with the whole picture! Nothing on this picture makes me want to claw my eyes out from the strain of reading! The only thing I would have done (if possible) would have been to get the vacuum posed differently. But other than that this is great! 9/10.
Comments from Judge Two:
Creativity...
+2 for a background image
+1 for the phrase having nothing to do to the game itself
+2 for finding images of John and a vaccum that fit oddly together. LOL
+1 for the subtle tribe pride in the corner.
CREATICITY: 6
As far as it being connected...it's perfectly connected. I don't see ANYTHING that would suggest otherwise. He's on a vaccum...and it looks like he's zooming away with it like he stole it. xD
CONNECTED: 10
ART MERIT: 8
Very classy, well put together, clean (pun intended) and yeah. Overall near perfect. It's not a 10 because I find myself asking why there is a vaccum in the jungle? o.O
+2 for a background image
+1 for the phrase having nothing to do to the game itself
+2 for finding images of John and a vaccum that fit oddly together. LOL
+1 for the subtle tribe pride in the corner.
CREATICITY: 6
As far as it being connected...it's perfectly connected. I don't see ANYTHING that would suggest otherwise. He's on a vaccum...and it looks like he's zooming away with it like he stole it. xD
CONNECTED: 10
ART MERIT: 8
Very classy, well put together, clean (pun intended) and yeah. Overall near perfect. It's not a 10 because I find myself asking why there is a vaccum in the jungle? o.O
Comments from Judge Three:
Beagle: 30/30. (It's just good shit)
That gives Beagle a score of 83.
Beagle Tribe wins immunity!
Tribal Council and Urn Room will be open soon. Patricia, we need a representative from Beagle for Tribal Council. If you don't choose someone in the next two hours, I'll pick somebody randomly.
Congrats guys!